If the
book is completely self contained, but is based in the same
world, does that make it a prequel?
Ummmm, yes.
I mean no.
Oh bugger.
I suppose if the same author wrote a book about the second world war,
and then also a book about the sailing of the mayflower, they'd be separate
entities.
However, if you were an alien reading the books, with no knowledge of the human
race, you might consider it a spoiler to learn that America was an independent
state, with a large army, and you'd want to read the mayflower book first.
I always try and order books according to the chronology of their setting.
David Gemmel's written a fair few novels, some of which are blatantly in the
same world, and feature the same places, and some of the same characters
(although I believe that ALL of his books are technically in the same
multiverse). In the case of his books, I'd generally recommend that as the
order of reading for newcommers.
Then again, Julian May's Intervention, etc. are definitely to be read after the
Many Coloured Land books, but that's partly because there's some "time-travel"
involved, and reading them first would spoil the plot of the series she wrote
first.
Lewis expressed a
vague preference for reading the books in Chronological order.
Then I'd have to go with that.
On the other hand reading them in the order that they were written
does kind of add to the magic. Finding out later, why the wardrobe
is magical and where the lampost came from, in my opinion does
add something to the reading.
Yet I do so reluctantly, and only because I've not read them in an awful long
time.
The beauty of TLTWATW is that it starts off with no knowledge of the world
assumed. The reader is (usually) a child in the present day, with pretty much
the same knowledge as the characters in the books. So as they find things out,
so does the reader. It's nice to stay in step like that. I can't remember how
the Magician's Nephew runs, but I'd want the starting point to any series to
be the book which reveals the "secrets" of the setting gradually, in a
plot-relevant manner.
Dominic.
"It matters not whether you win or lose;
what matters is whether I win or lose." [Darrin Weinberg]